Source: Reuters/Variety, September
30, 1997
By: Gary Graff
Portishead
''Portishead''
(Go! Beat/London)
2 stars
The individual details that
comprise Portishead's minimalist trip-hop are so arresting that
it's easy to praise this British group
without contemplating how well everything works together.
Vocalist Beth Gibbons' steely shriek is truly an original, and
Geoff
Barrow supplements it with a sonic bed that, while sparse and
moody, implies lushness. Spooky? Yes. But good? Not very.
Alternating between somnolent and grating, ``Portishead''
substitutes trendy form for substantive songwriting, resulting in
a
forest that doesn't look -- or sound -- nearly as good as the
trees.